Menupickcom lists publicly available information. We are not affiliated with the restaurants shown. How we source and check listings
Claim your listing

Menupickcom

Mary Zifer's Pizza In New Philly menu

6 dishes across 5 sections $1 to $10 Pizza restaurant

Prices transcribed from the printed menu, last checked

Menu Mary Zifer's Pizza In New Philly photo menu 1
Photographed in store, August 2026. See all 4 pages

Photos of the printed menu

Photographed in store in August 2026. The dish list below covers everything we could read clearly; the full card has more.

Mary Zifer's Pizza In New Philly photo menu 1

Pizza 10 dishes

  • Cheese US$9.05

  • Meat & Cheese US$9.55

  • Cheese & Green Peppers US$9.35

  • Cheese, Gr Pepper, & Mushrooms US$9.85

  • Meat, Cheese & Gr Pepper US$9.85

  • Meat, Cheese, Gr Pepper & Mushrooms US$10.35

  • Meat, Cheese, & Mushrooms US$10.05

  • Cheese & Mushrooms US$9.55

  • Low Fat (No Meat Or Cheese) US$10.35

    gr peppers, mushrooms, onions & hot peppers

  • Additional Toppings US$1.20

    hamburger, sausage, onions, hot peppers gr olives, black olives & anchovies

Pizza Subs 8 dishes

  • Cheese US$3.20

  • Meat & Cheese US$3.50

  • Meat, Cheese, Gr Pepper US$3.65

  • Meat, Cheese, & Mushrooms US$3.75

  • Meat, Cheese, Mushrooms, Gr Pepper US$3.95

  • Cheese & Mushrooms US$3.50

  • Cheese & Gr Peppers US$3.40

  • Cheese, Mushrooms, Gr Peppers US$3.70

Meatball Subs 2 dishes

  • Plain (no cheese) US$4.50

  • Splash (with cheese) US$5.00

Spaghetti & Rigatoni 2 dishes

  • Single US$5.00

  • Family Size US$10.00

Salads 1 dishes

  • Salads US$5.00

    house (vinaigrette) or sweet & sour dressings,

Breadsticks 1 dishes

  • Breadsticks US$4.50

About these prices

Restaurants change prices without notice, and a menu photographed in August may already be out of date. Treat these figures as a guide, not a quote. If you spot a difference, tell us and we will re-check it.

If you find yourself craving a delicious slice of pizza in New Philadelphia, you won’t want to miss Mary Zifer's Pizza in New Philly. Located at 145 2nd St NW, New Philadelphia, OH, this cozy pizza joint has earned a reputation for serving up some of the best comfort food in town. Whether you’re looking for a quick bite during lunch or a satisfying meal in the evening, Mary Zifer’s offers the perfect solution.

The restaurant has a warm, inviting vibe that makes it an ideal spot for anyone craving a casual, laid-back dining experience. Its menu focuses on all the comfort foods you love, with pizza being the star of the show. The crust is always fresh, topped with flavorful ingredients, and baked to perfection-sure to satisfy even the most discerning pizza lovers.

If you're in a rush or just prefer to enjoy your meal from the comfort of home, Mary Zifer's Pizza in New Philly makes it easy with their convenient delivery and takeaway service options. So whether you're swinging by for a quick pick-up or having it delivered to your door, you’ll never have to compromise on taste.

From the first bite to the last, this place promises to deliver a satisfying, quick meal with the kind of flavor that keeps customers coming back for more. With a focus on serving comfort food that’s both tasty and comforting, Mary Zifer’s Pizza in New Philly has become a go-to for locals and visitors alike.

Other menus in New Philadelphia

Prices transcribed the same way, each with the date last checked.

All New Philadelphia listings
Call Menu Directions